In Praise of Half-Baked Marketing
Saturday, September 6th, 2008If you’ve happened to ready more than one of these Marketing Wisdom blogs, then you know that I’m constantly harping about the fallacy that advertisers save money with D-I-Y, or “free” media-produced marketing, for the reason that the results from these “money saving” measures are generally ineffective in communicating a motivating message to the customer while extremely effective in branding the sponsor as an amateur business.
But, like with most everything, some good can come from these ‘half-baked’ marketing efforts…at least it can for the competitors of D-I-Y marketers or those who trust their marketing message to the hack work that comes from the media who promise to design and produce your marketing message for “free.”
Simply put, when you do your own logo – as opposed to hiring someone who actually does logos for a living – or entrust your marketing message to the ad salesman rather than pay a professional writer and / or designer to develop compelling words and pictures, you are making it just that much easier for your competitor to connect with customers.
Of course, in a market where pretty much every business does their marketing “in house” or relies on the TV-radio-newspaper-magazine to punch out ads and spots there’s a remarkable homogeneity to what you see in the paper, hear on the radio, and see on the TV.
Seriously, how many spots do we need where the smart wife/girl friend trumps the doltish, clueless husband or boyfriend?
Haven’t we all heard enough radio spots featuring dialogue between the studio engineer correcting the guy reading the copy?
Are you encouraged to patronize a business whose owner murders the language while reading the copy in his radio spot?
Don’t all of the bank ads showing a line-up of well-fed bankers in shirts and ties start looking the same to you?
Just because the newspaper sells ad space by the inch, do advertisers really get their money’s worth by packing every single inch with words and pictures?
And one of my favorites…
Even though computer design programs allow access to a mind-boggling number of fonts, are readers impressed when an ad contains 6 different fonts – each in a different color?
Interestingly, I’ll venture that almost none of the business men and women who pride themselves on their DIY marketing or their frugality when the media produces their advertising, cuts their own hair or allows the house painter to pick the color to paint their house.
Back to the point I was making when I began: half-baked marketing makes it that much easier for your competitor to produce ads, spots, direct mail, whatever that “stands apart” from the rest.
And when you consider that between 70% and 90% of the cost of any mass marketing effort is the cost of the media, e.g., getting the word out, it would stand to reason that one would want to justify this expense by making sure that the message, was as good as it could be.
This is why, whenever I see or hear a good ad or spot, I don’t immediately credit the creative folks. Instead I’m impressed by the person who was smart enough to pay a professional to make him or her look good.






