The Appeal of “Free” and Other Pitfalls
Monday, February 25th, 2008Anyone who is even casually aware of marketing can’t fail to appreciate the impact of the word “FREE.” Even though the world of mass marketing as we understand it is over 100 years old, few marketing tools have maintained their ability to provoke response more than the concept of “free.” It makes no difference that beginning with the Biblical Parables and ending with mom, mankind has been repeatedly urged to distrust the lure of getting something for nothing…to know avail.
Excuse me for a minute. I’ll be right back after I respond to an urgent e-mail from the Nigerian Finance Minister who needs my personal help with a small transfer of funds. I wonder how he got my name? Seriously, I’m constantly amazed at how often the promise of getting something for “nothing” will cause the brain higher centers of reasoning to completely shut down in otherwise savvy folks. Examples of this phenomenon abound, but since this a blog is mostly focused on marketing, advertising and related stuff I’ll confine my observations to instances where “free” seems to beat out “smart.”
For example, newspapers, radio and TV channels, magazines regularly offer to provide “free” creative services to advertisers. In my experience they will even discourage people from hiring ad agencies or creative consultants with the argument that doing so only ads to the cost of advertising. I suppose that would be true if the creative product of the agency or the consultant was no better than that of the media. Or, if the advertising couldn’t tell the difference. Or, if the advertiser doesn’t in fact understand that he or she can a better creative product, but doesn’t want to pay the price.
Think about that for a minute…
You’re going to spend some serious dough on a radio or TV campaign. That is, you will, unless you’ve been hornswoggled by some media rep into believing that spending $750 / month will actually do something for your bottom line…but I digress. You’ve decided to invest in a media effort, but you’re unwilling to spend any more money on creating a message that will stand out from the other messages that are literally bumping against yours on the page, radio or TV screen.
Instead, you’re willing to let the underpaid, overworked “production” staff of media you’re going to spend your hard-earned money on…create your ad for “free.” No matter that these folks are paid by the hour, have a ton of other “free” ads to do before the end of the day, and have no incentive whatsoever to make any one of these ads the slightest bit better than any of the others.
If that’s true, then you must subscribe to the axiom that it makes no difference what you say as long as you say it a lot. You also must delight in being unable to distinguish your message from that of your competitors, or for that matter, any other advertiser who’s availed themselves of the media’s “free” service.
“Nonsense!” I hear from the owner an auto body shop that has run a jingle ad campaign along the lines of, “We take the dents from your acci-dents at Otto’s Body Shop” about a thousand times on local radio stations. He swears that as a result everybody knows his name and comes in the door humming the jingle. No only that, he wrote the jingle himself and the radio station had some jingle guy in Nashville record it for $200 back in 1998.
Gosh, what can I say to a successful formula like that? Imagine: all you have to do is make up any old phrase with your business name it, and have some musicians and singers record it – making sure of course that the last word ends up on high note. Anyone can do it. In fact, everyone should do it. And judging from a random sample of radio, TV and magazine messages a lot of people are.
Frustrating? Not really. In fact, this is wonderful news for everyone who understands that: “You get what you pay for,” “There’s no such thing as a free lunch,” and my personal favorite, “A fool and his money are soon parted.” That’s because the prevalence of mediocre, cookie-cutter marketing messages makes it so much easier to cut through the clutter for anyone willing to say something about their company that’s original, interesting and touches the heart, soul and experience of their desired customer in a relevant manner.
Of course, unless you write such messages for a living, you might have to hire someone who does.






